FATHER CASIMIR J. FINLEY TROPHY
- 1956 Columbia-Cranford
- 1957 Leonia
- 1958 Seton Hall Prep
- 1959 Seton Hall Prep
- 1960 Summit
- 1961 Summit
- 1962 Plainfield
- 1963 Snyder
- 1964 Seton Hall Prep
- 1965 Seton Hall Prep
- 1966 Seton Hall Prep
- 1967 Hoboken
- 1968 Seton Hall Prep
- 1969 St. Peter’s (Jersey City)
- 1970 St. Peter’s (Jersey City)
- 1971 Montclair
- 1972 St. Peter’s (Jersey City)
- 1973 Montclair
- 1974 DePaul
- 1975 DePaul
- 1976 River Dell
- 1977 Passaic County Tech
- 1978 Passaic County Tech
- 1979 Monmouth Regional
- 1980 Christian Brothers Academy
- 1981 Manalapan
- 1982 Columbia
- 1983 Bishop Eustace
- 1984 Bishop Eustace
- 1985 Christian Brothers Academy
- 1986 Cherry Hill East
- 1987 Cherry Hill East
- 1988 Ramsey-Cherry Hill East-Camden
- 1989 Cherry Hill East
- 1990 Cherry Hill East-Columbia
- 1991 Cherry Hill East
- 1992 Cherry Hill East
- 1993 Ocean Township
- 1994 Wall Township
- 1995 Mountain Lakes
- 1996 Cherry Hill East
- 1997 Cherry Hill-Teaneck
- 1998 Lakewood
- 1999 St. Joseph-Metuchen
- 2000 St. Joseph-Metuchen
